Correspondence Address:
Dr Rahul R Mohare M.D. Scholar (Panchakarma) R. A. Podar Medical College, Worli, Mumbai (India). Email: rahulmohare1122@gmail.com
Date of Acceptance: 2024-04-10
Date of Publication:2024-04-30
Article-ID:IJIM_297_06_24 http://ijim.co.in
Source of Support: NILL
Conflict of Interest: NILL
How To Cite This Article: : Mohare R.R. Bahatkar S. The Efficacy of Virechana Karma and Shamana Upakrama in Pittaj Grahani with special reference to Gastroduodenitis : A Case Study. Int J Ind Med 2024;5(3):01-10 DOI: http://doi.org/10.55552/IJIM.2024.5301
In Ayurveda, Grahani roga (also known as Grahani disease) is a term used to describe various disorders related to the gastrointestinal tract, particularly those involving the small intestine and its functions. The term "Grahani" refers to the small intestine (place of Agni), which is considered the site of digestion and absorption of nutrients according to Ayurvedic principles. Based on dosha involved, it has four types namely- Vaataj, Pittaj, Kaphaj and Sannipataj. The condition Pittaj Grahani (Gastroduodenitis) was diagnosed in 23 years old female patient which was selected from Panchakarma OPD of our institute based on its classical symptoms and investigations. Total duration of therapy was 3 months which included Panchana deepana, Snehapana, Virechana karma, Samsarjan krama followed by Shamana Upachara using ayurvedic formulations. Parameters were assessed before and after treatment. As the patient was diagnosed based on classical symptoms of the disease the results were drawn using the gradations of parameters before and after the complete therapy. The treatment yield up to 80% relief from the symptoms. The motive behind this case report is to document the condition Pittaj Grahani which was treated successfully using Ayurvedic way of management i.e. with using Samshodhana (Virechana) and Shamana Upakrama. This case also highlights the importance of avoiding inappropriate diet and mismanaged lifestyle which may result in GIT Pathologies.
Keywords: Grahani roga, Sannipataj, Upakrama, Samsarjan krama, Virechana,
Panchakarma, also known as Samshodhana upakrama are the therapeutic procedures described in Ayurveda, which includes – Vamana (therapeutic emesis), Virechana (therapeutic purgation), Basti, Nasya and Raktamokshana.(1) Out of these pentamerous procedures Virechana, is the procedure of eliminating the doshas from body through lower gastrointestinal tract.(2) Virechana literally means to remove out something out of body by oral, nasal or by anal route, here the term is used to refer the elimination of doshas from lower gastrointestinal tract through the anal route. It is primarily indicated in management of diseases arising due to Pitta dosha(3) such as - Jwara, raktapitta, kamala, Visarpa, pandu etc. In Ayurveda, the vitiated doshas are managed either by Samshodhana or by Samshamana upakrama, but samshodhana being superior to samshamana has its uniqueness as the diseases are cured through their root cause by using this.(4) Virechana also establishes proper function of Jatharagni (digestive fire), as most of the diseases arises when the function of Jatharagni gets compromised;(5) mainly because of unhealthy, unwholesome food habits, lifestyle or by unsuitable weather conditions.(6) Grahani, is interpreted as one of the eight Maharogas, the diseases which are obstinate to treat as per Ayurvedic texts.(7) It is basically the place of Jatharagni situated above umbilicus having functions involved in the ingestion, digestion, absorption, assimilation and egestion of the food.(8) When these functions gets compromised the condition is termed as Grahani. The disease Grahani has four subtypes based on prominence of doshas involved – Vaataj, pittaj, Kaphaj and Sannipataj.(9) Amongs this, Pittaj Grahani presents with the classical symptoms like – Aruchi (tastelessness), Avipaak (Indigestion), Adhmaana (bloating), Amla udgar (acid irructation), Ura-Udardaah (burning in chest and abdomen), muhurbaddha muhurdrava mal pravritti (diarrhea and constipation accordingly) and general weakness.(10) This condition resembles with Gastroduodenitis. Gastroduodenitis is an intestinal condition caused by inflammation in duodenum lining. People suffering from this may have – feeling of fullness after eating, Bloating, Feeling sick, Cramping, Burning up and Nausea.(11) As Virechana is the best therapy for the Pitta dosha, in present case a 23 years old female patient having symptoms of Pittaj Grahani was treated with it along with Shamana Upachara. The case was assessed on subjective and objective parameters and some investigations. At the end of treatment and by following all the Pathya-apathya regulations patient got significant relief from the symptoms.
CASE REPORT:
A 23 years old female visited M A Podar Hospital, Mumbai having complains of – Urah- Udar daah prachiti (burning in chest and abdomen), Bhojanottar dravamal pravratti (loose motions after meal), Daurbalyanubhuti (general weakness), Udare vaat sanchiti (Belching), Avipaak (indigestion), and Hrillas (Nausea) since last 3 years especially after taking meal. Along with this patient was suffering from complains of Nasanaah (Nasal congestion) and frequent sneezing in morning hours and on exposure to cold environment. Patient initially took treatment from outside. Where she was diagnosed with Antral gastritis, Duodenitis and mild hiatus hernia and was suggested for operative procedure as part of management in July 2022. As patient was not ready for the operative, she visited Panchakarma OPD of our institute for Ayurveda treatment where patient was examined thoroughly and was diagnosed for Pittaj Grahani. Basic blood investigation, stool examination and Endoscopy was done.
DIAGNOSIS:
Before diagnosing the condition, the patient was examined using Ayurvedic methods of examination like – Trividh, Astavidha (12) and Dashavidha pariksha(13) thoroughly. The patient was having complains of – Ura and udar daah prachiti, udarshool, dravamal pravrutti (bhojanottar), Kshudhamandya, Trishnadhikya and Amlodgar on and off since 3 years; which were indicating Agnidushti and ultimately towards Grahani disease. The patient revealed no any history of serious past illness, the only family history was – DM (father), no any surgical history, no any history of any trauma before.
Personal History :
Ahara (Diet) – vegetarian diet with cereals, pulses, rice, vegetables, Street food items (guru, ushna vidahi ahara), Atitkaal bhojan
Vihara (Regime) – Pratah utthan – 8 am, Ratri shayan - 12 am, working hours 8, Exercise, Yoga for about 20 mins (Irregular)
Vyasana (Addiction) – NAD
Anurjata (Allergy) – allergic to dust, cold environment
General Examination (Astavidha Parikshana) :
Naadi (Pulse) - Vaatpitta Pradhan, vaat sthani, jalouka gati, alpa bal, 86/min
Mutra (urine) – Samyak pravrutti, 4-5 vegas a day
Mal (stool) – Dravamal pravrutti (bhojanottar), 3-4 episodes a day
Jivha (tongue) – Alpa saam
Shabda – Prakrut, Spasta
Sparsha – Prakrut, Anushna
Drik (Vision) - Prakrut
Akruti (Weight) – Madhyam krish
Koshtha - Mrudu
Agni - Manda
BP – 100/70 mmHg
Temp – 970 F
Dashavidha Pariksha :
Prakruti - Vaatpittaj
Vikruti – Annavaha srotas, Purishvaha srotas vikruti
Saar – Avara (poor)
Samhanana : Madhyama
Satmya : Madhur ras,tikta ras ahara dravya, Katu lavan ras Asatmya
Aharshakti : Avara
Satva – Pravar
Vyayamshakti : Avara
Praman – Saardha trihasta, 84 angul
Vaya – Balavastha – 23 year
Nidaan Panchak:
Hetu: Katu-Amla-lavana ras, Ushna, vidaahi guru bhojan (street food items), Atitkaal bhojan, Kshudha veg dharana
Purvaroop : Anna vidaah (heart burn aft eating), Excessive thirst, general weakness
Roop: Urah- Udar daah prachiti (burning in chest and abdomen), Bhojanottar dravamal pravratti (loose motions after meal), Daurbalyanubhuti (general weakness), Udare vaat sanchiti (Belching), Avipaak (indigestion), and Hrillas (Nausea)
Upashaya: Madhur, tikta ras sevan Anupashaya– Katu , amla, guru ahar sevan
Samprapti (Pathogenesis):
Investigations: The patient underwent blood investigations, stool examinations which were nil and doesn’t reveal anything and the Endoscopy which showed – antral gastritis, duodenitis and mild hiatus hernia at GE junction. The blood investigation values were – Hb – 10.2 gm/dl, WBC – 5200 per microliter, Neutrophils % - 60%, eosinophils – Monocyte % - 06%, Platelet – 358000 per microliter, Basophils% - 00%, Lymphocyte % - 29%
TREATMENT PLAN:
Acharya Charak, in Grahanidosh chikitsa adhyay has given plan for the management of Pittaj Grahani,(14) where its indicated to undergo samshodhana upakrama and expel out vitiated pitta dosha using either by virechana or by vamana karma. The patient was vitally stable but was not fit for vamana karma because of her Sukumar prakruti (delicate body nature). Initially patient was treated with Samshamana upachara for more than a month by using some Ayurvedic formulations as given in table 1. The symptoms of Saam avastha and associated complains like nasal congestion, frequent sneezes were managed.
After managing the condition using formulations, the patient was advised to undergo Virechana. As the act of removing saam dosha is contra indicated. (21) The patient was Planned for Virechana initially by Rukshana, Pachana and deepana upakrama using the combination of Ayurvedic drugs – Triphala, Musta and Shunthi churna for 1 week. The patient was re- examined before Snehapaana, consent was taken in written form. The Snehapaana was given with the combination of Mahatikta ghrita(22) and Yashtimadhu ghrit(23) in half amount each
The patient was advised to take Sneha (combination of Mahatikta and Yashtimadhu ghrit) in early morning with lukewarm water as Anupana, to drink lukewarm water whenever felt thirsty. The diet advised was of Laghu, drava, alpa snigdha and ushna guna (light, semisolid and bland diet) during Snehapaana and also for three days rest after Snehapaana. Following of Pathya-apathya regime was also advised strictly. After 5 days of consuming this Sneha, patient showed signs of samayak snehapaan like – Purish snigdhata, vit shaithilya, Adhastat Sneha darshan, Sneha dwesha and gaatra snigdhata. The Snehapaana vidhi is described in table no. 2
Before posting to the Virechana karma patient underwent whole body oleation and sudation therapy (Sarvanga Snehana and Swedana), both before one day and on the Virechana day. The Patient was examined prior to the karma using astavidha pareekshana vidhi, Abdomen palpation and percussion and general examinations as follows:
Naadi – Vaatpitta Pradhan, Laghu, having Jalouka gati with rate of 70/min
Mutra – Samyak pravritti, 4-5 vegas a day
Mal – samyak pravritti, 1-2 vegas a day
Jivha – Niraam
Shabda – Spasta, prakrut
Sparsha – Parkrut, anushna
Drik – Prakrut
Akruti – Madhyam krish
Koshtha – Mrudu
Agni – Prakrut
BP – 110/70 mmHg
RR – 18/min
Temp – 97.20 F
P/A – Soft, non-tender
After examining thoroughly, Virechana aushadhi – Trivrittavaleha(24) was given in 60 gm amount with Draksha faant as anupana at late morning 10:30 am. Draksha faant was also used as Virechanopag(25) to enhance the procedure of purgation. Total virechana vegas were 16 with Samyak shuddhi lakshanas at the end. Patient was advised to follow Peyadi Samsarjana krama for the next 5 days with regime of Pathya-apathya. Follow up after 14 days of completion of samsarjana krama.
TREATMENT OUTCOMES: General examinations were done on follow up day, patient was vitally stable. The main complains were assessed using gradation and compared before and after treatment.The treatment yield near about 80% relief from the symptoms when compared with the symptoms on first follow up. There was significant improvement in the health of patient after virechana karma. The patient was advised to take Mahatikta ghrit – 10 ml twice a day at rasayana kaal for the next 21 days as shamana upachara with Jeerak, Shatapushpa churna 3 gm and Praval panchamrit ras 250 mg BD after meal.
Virechana, is the best treatment of Pitta dosha. Which also establishes proper function of Jatharagni (digestive fire). Here in presenting case the symptoms were indicating pitta dushti, Agnidushti and ultimately its place “grahani” as well. The management was done according to the treatment principles explained in Grahanidushti chikitsa adhyay(26) by Charaka acharya. The snehapaana, prior to virechana was given with combination of Mahatikta and Yashtimadhu ghrit to oleate body inside out, to liquify doshas and make dosha vriddhi. After sarvang snehana an swedana for movement of dosha from shakha to koshtha. With the help of virechana these doshas can be eliminated through lower gastrointestinal track. Virechana karma was done using “Trivruttavaleha” as “Trivrutta” ( Operculina turpethum) is “ sukhvirechak” aushadhi and can be used in Sukumar vyakti.(27) It is Madhur ras aushadi virechak kalpa and easily palatable for the patients. Patient got 16 vegas of virechana and peyadi samsarjan krama was advised for the next 5 days to establish Jatharagni again. After 14 days of completing it, patient was having significant relief from the symptoms. Mahatikta ghrita is Swadutikta aushadi kalpa and is mentioned to use in treating Pittaj grahani.(28) It is used in shamana matra (10 ml) also to work on Pittadhara kala i.e. on Grahani (29) itself along with this Panchamrit parpati (30) is used as vyadhi pratyanik medicine. The patient is still on follow up and has no symptoms related to Pittaj Grahani (Gastroduodenitis) these days.
The motive behind this case report is to document the condition Pittaj Grahani which was treated successfully using Ayurvedic way of management i.e. with using Samshodhana (Virechana) and Shamana Upakrama. This case also highlights the importance of avoiding inappropriate diet and mismanaged lifestyle which may result in GIT Pathologies.
Achaya vagbhata, Ashtang Hridayam, with commentaries “sarvanga sundara” of Arunadatta and “Ayurvedarasayana” of Hemadri, edited by Pt. Hari Sadashiv Paradkara, Publisher Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthan, Varanasi, Edition 2016, page no. 223
Acharya vidyadhar shukl, Prof. Ravi Dutt Tripathi, Caraksamhita of agnivesa, “vaidyamanorama” hindi commentary, published by – Chaukhamba Sanskrit Pratishthan, Delhi, Edition 2017, Page no. 805
Acharya Charak, Caraka-samhita, “Ayurvedadipika” commentary by Sri Cakrapanidatta, Edited by Vaidya Yadavji Trikamji Acharya, Published by Chukhamba Surbharati Prakashan, Varanasi, Edition 2019, page no. 131
Acharya Charak, Caraka-samhita, “Ayurvedadipika” commentary by Sri Cakrapanidatta, Edited by Vaidya Yadavji Trikamji Acharya, Published by Chukhamba Surbharati Prakashan, Varanasi, Edition 2019, page no. 97
Achaya vagbhata, Ashtang Hridayam, with commentaries “sarvanga sundara” of Arunadatta and “Ayurvedarasayana” of Hemadri, edited by Pt. Hari Sadashiv Paradkara, Publisher Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthan, Varanasi, Edition 2016, page no. 513
Acharya vidyadhar shukl, Prof. Ravi Dutt Tripathi, Caraksamhita of agnivesa, “vaidyamanorama” hindi commentary, published by – Chaukhamba Sanskrit Pratishthan, Delhi, Edition 2017, Page no. 367
Achaya vagbhata, Ashtang Hridayam, with commentaries “sarvanga sundara” of Arunadatta and “Ayurvedarasayana” of Hemadri, edited by Pt. Hari Sadashiv Paradkara, Publisher Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthan, Varanasi, Edition 2016, page no. 497
Acharya vidyadhar shukl, Prof. Ravi Dutt Tripathi, Caraksamhita of agnivesa, “vaidyamanorama” hindi commentary, published by – Chaukhamba Sanskrit Pratishthan, Delhi, Edition 2017, Page no. 369
Acharya vidyadhar shukl, Prof. Ravi Dutt Tripathi, Caraksamhita of agnivesa, “vaidyamanorama” hindi commentary, published by – Chaukhamba Sanskrit Pratishthan, Delhi, Edition 2017, Page no. 370
Acharya vidyadhar shukl, Prof. Ravi Dutt Tripathi, Caraksamhita of agnivesa, “vaidyamanorama” hindi commentary, published by – Chaukhamba Sanskrit Pratishthan, Delhi, Edition 2017, Page no. 370
Article reviewed by Melinda Ratinik, MS, DO, www.WebMD.com (visited on 9/02/2023)
Vaidya Srilakshmipati Shastri ayurvedacharya, Yogaratnakar, “Vidyotini” hindi commentary, published by Chaukhamba Prakashan, Varanasi, edition : reprint 2020, Page no. 5
Acharya Charak, Caraka-samhita, “Ayurvedadipika” commentary by Sri Cakrapanidatta, Edited by Vaidya Yadavji Trikamji Acharya, Published by Chukhamba Surbharati Prakashan, Varanasi, Edition 2019, page no. 278
Acharya vidyadhar shukl, Prof. Ravi Dutt Tripathi, Caraksamhita of agnivesa, “vaidyamanorama” hindi commentary, published by – Chaukhamba Sanskrit Pratishthan, Delhi, Edition 2017, Page no. 377
Vaidya Srilakshmipati Shastri ayurvedacharya, Yogaratnakar, “Vidyotini” hindi commentary, published by Chaukhamba Prakashan, Varanasi, edition : reprint 2020, Page no. 244
Kaviraj Sri govinda das senavirachita, Bhaisajya Ratnavali, edited with “Siddhiprada” Hindi commentary by Prof. Siddji Nandan Mishra, Published by – Chaukhamba Surbharati Prakashan, Varanasi, Edition 2017, page no. 259
Kaviraj Sri govinda das senavirachita, Bhaisajya Ratnavali, edited with “Siddhiprada” Hindi commentary by Prof. Siddji Nandan Mishra, Published by – Chaukhamba Surbharati Prakashan, Varanasi, Edition 2017, page no. 178
Acharya Charak, Caraka-samhita, “Ayurvedadipika” commentary by Sri Cakrapanidatta, Edited by Vaidya Yadavji Trikamji Acharya, Published by Chukhamba Surbharati Prakashan, Varanasi, Edition 2019, page no. 464
Kaviraj Sri govinda das senavirachita, Bhaisajya Ratnavali, edited with“Siddhiprada” Hindi commentary by Prof. Siddji Nandan Mishra, Published by – Chaukhamba Surbharati Prakashan, Varanasi, Edition 2017, page no. 659
Kaviraj Sri govinda das senavirachita, Bhaisajya Ratnavali, edited with“Siddhiprada” Hindi commentary by Prof. Siddji Nandan Mishra, Published by – Chaukhamba Surbharati Prakashan, Varanasi, Edition 2017, page no. 392
Achaya vagbhata, Ashtang Hridayam, with commentaries “sarvanga sundara” of Arunadatta and “Ayurvedarasayana” of Hemadri, edited by Pt. Hari Sadashiv Paradkara, Publisher Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthan, Varanasi, Edition 2016, page no. 217
Acharya Charak, Caraka-samhita, “Ayurvedadipika” commentary by Sri Cakrapanidatta, Edited by Vaidya Yadavji Trikamji Acharya, Published by Chukhamba Surbharati Prakashan, Varanasi, Edition 2019, page no. 457
Achaya vagbhata, Ashtang Hridayam, with commentaries “sarvanga sundara” of Arunadatta and “Ayurvedarasayana” of Hemadri, edited by Pt. Hari Sadashiv Paradkara, Publisher Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthan, Varanasi, Edition 2016, page no. 594
Achaya vagbhata, Ashtang Hridayam, with commentaries “sarvanga sundara” of Arunadatta and “Ayurvedarasayana” of Hemadri, edited by Pt. Hari Sadashiv Paradkara, Publisher Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthan, Varanasi, Edition 2016, page no. 742
Acharya Charak, Caraka-samhita, “Ayurvedadipika” commentary by Sri Cakrapanidatta, Edited by Vaidya Yadavji Trikamji Acharya, Published by Chukhamba Surbharati Prakashan, Varanasi, Edition 2019, page no. 33
Acharya Charak, Caraka-samhita, “Ayurvedadipika” commentary by Sri Cakrapanidatta, Edited by Vaidya Yadavji Trikamji Acharya, Published by Chukhamba Surbharati Prakashan, Varanasi, Edition 2019, page no. 511
Acharya Charak, Caraka-samhita, “Ayurvedadipika” commentary by Sri Cakrapanidatta, Edited by Vaidya Yadavji Trikamji Acharya, Published by Chukhamba Surbharati Prakashan, Varanasi, Edition 2019, page no. 662
Acharya Charak, Caraka-samhita, “Ayurvedadipika” commentary by Sri Cakrapanidatta, Edited by Vaidya Yadavji Trikamji Acharya, Published by Chukhamba Surbharati Prakashan, Varanasi, Edition 2019, page no. 377
Maharshi Susruta, Susruta Samhita uttartantra, “ayurvedatattva sandipika” hindi commentary by – Dr Ambika datt shastri, published by- Chaukhamba Sanskrit Sansthan, Varanasi, Edition : 2018, Page no. 306
Kaviraj Sri govinda das senavirachita, Bhaisajya Ratnavali, edited with “Siddhiprada” Hindi commentary by Prof. Siddji Nandan Mishra, Published by – Chaukhamba Surbharati Prakashan, Varanasi, Edition 2017, page no. 292
"